Pine Island Shores Homes for Sale

Pine Island Shores Homes for Sale

Welcome to Pine Island Shores, a hidden gem nestled along the stunning coastline of Florida! This charming subdivision is located on Pine Island, known for its lush landscapes, serene atmosphere, and breathtaking waterfront views. If you’re seeking a tranquil retreat that combines the beauty of nature with the comforts of modern living, Pine Island Shores is the perfect place to call home.

The homes for sale in Pine Island Shores reflect the unique character of this coastal paradise. With a diverse range of architectural styles, from quaint beach cottages to contemporary waterfront estates, there’s something to suit every taste and lifestyle. Many properties boast spacious layouts, updated amenities, and private outdoor spaces that invite you to enjoy the Florida sunshine year-round. Imagine sipping your morning coffee while watching the sunrise over the tranquil waters or hosting gatherings in your backyard oasis.

Beyond the beautiful homes, Pine Island Shores offers a vibrant community atmosphere. Residents can enjoy easy access to pristine beaches, local parks, and a plethora of recreational activities, including fishing, kayaking, and biking along scenic trails. The nearby charming shops and eateries provide a delightful taste of island life, making it easy to embrace the laid-back Florida lifestyle.

Whether you’re looking for a permanent residence, a vacation getaway, or an investment opportunity, Pine Island Shores offers a unique blend of coastal charm and modern convenience. Discover your dream home in this idyllic subdivision and experience the beauty of island living today!

Newest Pine Island Shores Homes for Sale

35546 Calla Court, Leesburg
$699,900
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Pine Island Shores SubDv. ⋅ 34788 Zip Code
Step Back in Time Without Giving Up Modern Comforts! This Waterfront Mid-Century Gem Is Seriously COOL! Love Mid-century architecture? You're going to fall for this one-of-a-kind 1957 waterfront property! Bursting with retro personality and vintage charm, it offers 201 feet of canal frontage just off Lake Eustis, access to the Harris Chain of Lakes, an oversized screened pool (10 feet deep!), and incredible entertaining spaces. The main home celebrates its mid-century roots with beautifully restored original Tennessee pink terrazzo floors and classic architectural details. The kitchen and main bathroom were updated in 2020, including an induction cooktop and convection oven, other improvements include replacement windows (2019), most of the electrical wiring updated, steel exterior entry doors (2019, excluding front and patio doors), added attic insulation, and new roofs in 2019–2020. Both buildings feature tankless water heaters. The second building offers over 1,200 square feet of possibilities! A renovated studio apartment (2020–2021) has enjoyed excellent short-term rental reviews and features a private patio and barbecue area. It's ideal for guests, extended family, or potential rental income. The adjoining lodge-style gathering space showcases a massive brick fireplace, original mid-century built-ins, vintage green linoleum floors, and kitchenette areas—perfect for parties, game nights, hobbies, and family gatherings. The oversized screened pool area is your own private retro resort! Highlights include a 10-foot-deep end, curved entry steps, original fiberglass slide, stainless-steel diving board dating to approximately 1963, and shallow-end spa jets. Fabulous decorative breeze block, a vintage pool bar, covered dining area with TV, generous entertaining space, and a large pool bathroom with shower complete this incredible outdoor retreat. Boating enthusiasts will love the 201 feet of canal frontage, two covered docks with electricity, and space for two additional boats. Enjoy cruising, fishing, and boating to waterfront restaurants along the beautiful Harris Chain of Lakes! Additional features include a large glass greenhouse, enclosed garage with coated floors, spacious workshop with potential vehicle or recreational storage, matching 10 x 10 storage shed, two driveways, and ample parking. A private well supplies household water, while canal water serves irrigation. Water treatment was updated in 2021 and 2026, and the septic systems mean no municipal water or sewer bills. A little retro, a little funky, and a whole lot of fabulous! With authentic 1950s-character, modern updates, separate guest quarters, exceptional entertaining spaces, and a prime waterfront location, this is more than a home—it's a rare opportunity to enjoy Old Florida charm and an unforgettable waterfront lifestyle!

35546 Calla Court, Leesburg

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!